How we rate American casinos for UK players
Every score on this site comes out of the same seven criteria with the same weights, and the questions below are the ones readers send us about them. The short version: licensing carries more weight than any offer, and no match percentage moves a brand past an operator we can identify.
What are the criteria and what is each one worth?
Seven criteria, weighted to one hundred. The order is the same on the homepage as on every subpage, and a brand that has no data for a weighted criterion cannot score at the top of it.
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Licensing and operator background | 28% |
| Payments and withdrawal speed | 16% |
| Bonus terms | 13% |
| Verification and account rules | 13% |
| Game library and providers | 10% |
| Responsible-gambling tools | 10% |
| Support and site quality | 10% |
Why does licensing carry 28%?
Because it is the only part of an offshore account a reader cannot judge from the lobby, and it decides what happens when something goes wrong. A site that names its authority and its licence number can be looked up; a site that shows a badge and no number cannot. The brands we rank highest are the ones where the regulator, the number and the holding company all appear in the terms, and the first of those three is the minimum. Curacao, Anjouan and Panama are not equivalents of a Gambling Commission licence, and we do not present them as one.
What keeps a casino off the list entirely?
Four things. An operator nobody can name, with no company and no jurisdiction in the terms. A site that does not say whether it accepts players from the United Kingdom. A cashier that offers no route a British player can actually use. And a bonus structure whose wagering base is not stated anywhere, because a multiple without a base is not a number a reader can work with.
What do you check specifically for players in the UK?
Four UK-specific facts, and they appear on every page because they change what the account is worth. Whether the operator holds a Gambling Commission licence, which none of the offshore brands we cover does. Whether the site sits outside GAMSTOP, which every operator without a Commission licence does, with the consequence stated as a limitation and never as a selling point. Whether the account can be funded and paid out in sterling, or whether euros and dollars mean a conversion each way. And what the local protections are worth in a dispute: outside a Commission licence there is no approved dispute-resolution body and no complaints route to the regulator.
Two facts we also publish because readers ask: gambling winnings are not taxable income in the UK whatever licence the operator holds, and credit-card gambling has been banned on Commission-licensed sites since April 2020, so a site that still accepts a credit card is showing you where it is licensed.
How often is a score revisited?
When the underlying value changes. Bonus terms, payout windows and accepted countries move without notice at offshore brands, so a score is a snapshot of what the terms and the register said when the page was written, and a page is re-edited when a figure we published no longer matches the source. The date under the article shows when the page was last updated.
Do operators pay for a better score?
No. Some links on this site are affiliate links and a commission can be paid when a reader opens an account through one, which is how the research is funded. It buys no part of a ranking. The same seven criteria decide the order for operators who pay and operators who do not, and brands with no commercial relationship appear in our comparisons whenever the data puts them there.
What can this method not tell you?
Three things, and they are worth more than another paragraph of reassurance. We do not run accounts at every casino we list, so the payout windows on this site are the ones the operator states, not stopwatch figures. A licence that is valid when a page is written can lapse later, and only the register shows that. And no rubric predicts how a given operator will behave over a large win: a track record and a named licence holder shorten the odds, they do not remove the risk.
Who does the rating?
Owen Bradbury writes and scores the comparisons on this site; he has covered online casinos for seven years and the pages he writes carry his byline and his email address. There is no panel of anonymous experts behind him and no second brand name on the masthead, and corrections from readers go straight to him.